Bible Questions
  • Home
  • Topics
    • Popular
    • Steps to Salvation
    • Seeking a Church?
    • A - E >
      • A
      • B
      • C
      • D
      • E
    • F - J >
      • F
      • G
      • H
      • I
      • J
    • K - O >
      • K
      • L
      • M
      • N
      • O
    • P - T >
      • P
      • R
      • S
      • T
    • U - Z >
      • U
      • V
      • W
      • Z
  • Lessons
    • Baptism
    • Bible Basics
    • How to Study >
      • Interpreting the Bible
      • Effective Bible Study
    • Bible Surveys >
      • Beginner Bible Survey
      • Advanced BIble Survey >
        • Old Testament Survey
        • Major and Minor Prophets
        • New Testament Survey
      • Old Testament Characters
    • Book Surveys >
      • Ecclesiastes
      • Sermon on the Mount
      • Acts of the Apostles
      • Romans
      • Ephesians
      • Philippians
      • 1 & 2 Thessalonians
      • 1 & 2 Timothy, Titus
      • James
      • 1 & 2 Peter
      • 1, 2, 3 John
      • Jude
    • Christian Living >
      • Adding to Your Faith
      • Christian Evidences
      • Parables of Jesus
      • Personal Evangelism
      • Practical Christianity
      • Prayer
      • Self-Assessment
      • Supernatural Power
    • The Church >
      • Church History
      • Leadership
      • Work of the Church
  • Podcasts
  • Ask Question
  • About Us
  • Study Aids
  • Blog
  • Sermons
  • Baptism Debate 2011
  • Privacy Policy

Faith: “A Crutch for the Weak” or Brilliant Deduction?

3/28/2015

 
Introduction.  No one who has read the stories of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle about his famous character Sherlock Holmes or watched a show on forensic science has any doubt about the great power of deductive reasoning. With it people see what others can’t see and succeed where others fail. The power of deduction lies in its amazing ability to go beyond the five senses. Because time moves, what we see, hear, touch, taste, or smell can only give limited information. The crime scene no longer holds all the answers since the criminal has left. Yet inferences and logical conclusions can recreate what could have been easily seen just moments earlier. The detective using inference and logic can recreate the events with hair, skin, footprints, blood, and so on.
Logic and inference have created all our appliances and technology. They have allowed us to teach history and science to children. They have changed medicine into an amazing science where multitudes of things previously unknown are now easily understood. They have enhanced our lives in ways impossible to imagine a few generations back.

While for centuries people saw lighting strike, someone deduced that this force could be used as a source of energy. For centuries people could see, hear, and think. But only in the last century did some deduce these things could be reproduced. Through deduction we now have a computer, camera, CD, DVD, and tape recorder. Everyone extols the inventor, doctor, lawyer, or detective for their astute and accurate use of logic and deduction.

Yet an amazing paradox occurs when the Christian uses logic and deduction. There can be no debate that exactly the same methods are used to conclude God created the heavens and the earth, Jesus is the Son of God, or all Scripture is given by inspiration. Yet when people use logic and deduction to see these things, few today will praise that effort. In fact, many people feel a need to mock or scorn using derisive terms like “gullible,” “superstitious,” or using “a crutch for the weak.” 

God called the logical conclusions based on deductive reasoning "faith". A believer takes facts and deduces conclusions just like Sherlock Holmes. Faith is the “evidence of things not seen” (Heb. 11:1). Think about it! That is exactly what any good forensic scientist does. When the inventor, doctor, or lawyer finds faith, it is brilliant. Why should it be any less for the Christian? God revealed that those who see his invisible attributes in the material creation are only making the proper deductions based on what he left behind as evidence.
  • For his invisible attributes, namely, his eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly perceived, ever since the creation of the world, in the things that have been made. So they are without excuse. (Rom 1:20-21)
It is deduction that allows us to see invisible attributes of God in the things that are made. While the criminal does everything possible to erase his presence, God left things so he could easily be found. This evidence is so clear that there is no valid excuse to miss it. Just as a lawyer “sees” invisible things based upon deduction, we “see” God’s eternal power through deduction. Just as a doctor diagnoses an “invisible” illness through deduction, we “diagnose” God’s “invisible” divine nature in the things that are made. While most people only see a material creation, the Christian using deduction sees God.

How can the man who sees God in the evidence left behind in the creation be a fool and the detective who finds the criminal in the evidence left behind be a genius? There is no difference in the method. Both use pure deductive and logical reasoning. When a prosecutor and defense attorney do not agree about the guilt or innocence, we do not scoff at their methods. We look at the facts and draw our own conclusion.

Scientists and Christians are looking at the same facts using the same methods, yet drawing different conclusions. Yet many today are not interested in debating the facts like lawyers in a trial. When the method is identical and the detective is praised while the Christian mocked, it is simply a sign of bias and prejudice. How can it be wisdom for the detective to infer from evidence and the Christian be “gullible” and “leaning on a crutch” using exactly the methods?

Conclusion. God himself has revealed how easy it is to see him every day and every night.
  • The heavens declare the glory of God; and the firmament shows His handiwork. 2 Day unto day utters speech, and night unto night reveals knowledge. 3 There is no speech nor language where their voice is not heard. 4 Their line has gone out through all the earth, and their words to the end of the world. (Ps 19:1-4)
When we see what is so obvious, we are only using the wisdom of deductive logic. While the world may mock and scorn, God will praise us in the last day. 

Comments are closed.

    Alan Hitchen

    Alan is a preacher for the Holly Street church of Christ in Denver, CO. He has preached in various other locations in his +35 year career.  He is also active in spreading the Gospel to Malawi, Africa.

 Bible Questions is a work of the Holly Street church of Christ in Denver, CO. 
Copyright (c) 2025 Holly Street church of Christ. All material within the website may be freely distributed for non-commercial uses by including a reference to the website.