Why did Jesus say “Do not touch Me.”?
Introduction. The full question is “Why did Jesus tell Mary Magdalene not to touch Him (John 20:17), yet later invite Thomas to touch Him?” Note the KJV has “Touch me not”, the NKJV and ESV have “Do not cling to me”, the NIV has “Do not hold on to me”, and the NASB has “Stop clinging to me”.
On the surface, this sounds like a contradiction. However, on closer examination, we’ll see this isn’t the case.
With Mary Magdalene. Let’s start with the beginning of John 20 to set the stage for verse 17. After going to the tomb early Sunday morning and observing the stone over the entrance rolled away, Mary ran to tell Peter and John. After they ran to the tomb, Mary returned. Notice in verses 11, 13, and 15 she was distraught and weeping because she thought Jesus body had been moved (vs. 13, 15), hindering her from properly anointing the body for burial (Mark 16:1).
Jesus saying “Do not cling to me…” in vs. 17 necessarily implies that’s what she had done when she joyfully realized the supposed gardener as her risen Lord (vs. 16)! The key to understanding what He meant is to realize “cling” or “touch” comes from a Greek word meaning “to fasten one's self to, adhere to, cling to”. This is not just a mere touch as the KJV suggests.
The same verse explains why - because Jesus is about to return to His Father, not remain on the earth.
With Thomas. Later on in chapter 20, the situation with Thomas is very different. As you can read in verses 24-29, Jesus’ invitation to Thomas to touch Him was to settle his doubts regarding Jesus’ identity and bodily resurrection.
Conclusion. This is a good example of closely examining both the context and the meaning of words to help resolve alleged Biblical contradictions.
On the surface, this sounds like a contradiction. However, on closer examination, we’ll see this isn’t the case.
With Mary Magdalene. Let’s start with the beginning of John 20 to set the stage for verse 17. After going to the tomb early Sunday morning and observing the stone over the entrance rolled away, Mary ran to tell Peter and John. After they ran to the tomb, Mary returned. Notice in verses 11, 13, and 15 she was distraught and weeping because she thought Jesus body had been moved (vs. 13, 15), hindering her from properly anointing the body for burial (Mark 16:1).
Jesus saying “Do not cling to me…” in vs. 17 necessarily implies that’s what she had done when she joyfully realized the supposed gardener as her risen Lord (vs. 16)! The key to understanding what He meant is to realize “cling” or “touch” comes from a Greek word meaning “to fasten one's self to, adhere to, cling to”. This is not just a mere touch as the KJV suggests.
The same verse explains why - because Jesus is about to return to His Father, not remain on the earth.
With Thomas. Later on in chapter 20, the situation with Thomas is very different. As you can read in verses 24-29, Jesus’ invitation to Thomas to touch Him was to settle his doubts regarding Jesus’ identity and bodily resurrection.
Conclusion. This is a good example of closely examining both the context and the meaning of words to help resolve alleged Biblical contradictions.